It depends on why you're leaving. For simple, cookieless traffic numbers: Plausible, Fathom or Simple Analytics. For a full Google Analytics replacement you can self-host: Matomo. For product analytics with replay and feature flags: PostHog. For free session replay alongside another tool: Microsoft Clarity. For analytics that explains why your numbers changed, with replay, heatmaps and an intent score for every visitor: WysLeap.
Updated
Google Analytics 4 is free and powerful, but the reasons teams look elsewhere come up again and again: it sets cookies, so in the EU it usually needs a consent banner and loses the visitors who decline; its interface is hard to get answers out of; and visitor data goes to Google. Which alternative is best depends on which of those you're trying to fix.
These are the right choice if collecting as little as possible matters most. They report aggregate numbers, so they don't do session replay, heatmaps or per-visitor analysis.
WysLeap covers the core Google Analytics reports (traffic, sources, campaigns, journeys and funnels) without cookies, and adds the part most tools leave to you: WysAI looks at your own data and explains why traffic or conversions changed, with the likely causes, the evidence for each and a suggested fix.
It works at the visitor level, so it collects more than Plausible or Fathom, and in the EU/UK it waits for consent. There's no free plan: Pro is $30 a month after a 90-day free trial. Read the full WysLeap vs Google Analytics comparison.
Side by side
Defaults as documented by each vendor. Most tools can be configured differently.
| Feature | WysLeap | Plausible | Fathom | Matomo | PostHog | Clarity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No cookies by default | Setting | Setting | ||||
| Traffic analytics | Basic | |||||
| Session replay and heatmaps | Plugin | |||||
| Explains why traffic or conversions changed | Ask its AI | |||||
| Per-visitor intent score | ||||||
| Self-hosting option | Community edition | |||||
| Free option | 90-day trial | Trial | Trial | Self-hosted | Free tier |
"Setting": Matomo and PostHog can run without cookies after a configuration change. "Plugin": Matomo's heatmaps and session recording are a paid plugin. "Ask its AI": PostHog's AI assistant answers questions about your data when you ask. Check each vendor's current documentation and pricing before you decide.
FAQ
Other guides
Analytics that explains why visitors drop off. 90-day free trial, no cookies.